NARRATIVE SOVEREIGNTY, EMOTIONS AND INTERSPECIES RELATIONSHIPS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21153/cinder2019art880Keywords:
narrative sovereignty, emotions, dingoes, human–animal relationships, creative non-fictionAbstract
This article engages the claim that narrative is crucial to humans’ capacity to imagine and to know other animals. It brings together the concept of political sovereignty from Derrida, with an evaluation of emotion to analyse narratives about interspecies relationships. I begin by mapping Derrida’s critique of the relationship between violence and scientific knowledge about animals (Derrida 2009: 276–304) onto recent research into relationships between people and dingoes on K’gari (Fraser Island), to delineate how violent epistemologies may underpin humans’ ways of knowing other animals. I then explore the politics of the public education about dingoes on K’gari as they relate to government policies and the way the state exercises power; such state-sanctioned narratives set the discursive tone for the way people know and interact with (this) other species, and disallow other epistemologies. In contrast, creative nonfiction narrators Barry Lopez (Of Wolves and Men, 2004) and Helen Macdonald (H Is for Hawk, 2014) perform their own critiques of inaccurate and controlling narratives about, respectively, wolves and goshawks. I argue that the techniques they use—acknowledging emotion; observing animals’ perceptions, relationships and agency; respecting animals’ ability to resist human-imposed meanings; recognising the limits of human knowledge; and incorporating other voices—provide a framework for how creative writers may narrate other animals more ethically and more accurately.
References
Allen, BL, K Higginbottom, JH Bracks, N Davies, and GS Baxter 2015 ‘Balancing dingo conservation with human safety on Fraser Island: the numerical and demographic effects of humane destruction of dingoes’ Australian Journal of Environmental Management 22 (2), 197–215, doi.org/10.1080/14486563.2014.999134
Balme, J and S O’Connor 2016 ‘Dingoes and Aboriginal social organisation in Holocene Australia’, Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 7, 775–81, doi: org/10.1016/j.jasrep.2015.08.015
Behrendorff, L 2015 Interview with author, Eurong QLD, 26 November
Behrendorff, L and BL Allen 2016 ‘From den to dust: longevity of three dingoes (Canis lupus dingo) on Fraser Island (K’gari)’ Australian Mammalogy 38 (2), 256–60, doi: 10.1071/AM17024
Carter, J, A Wardell-Johnson, and C Archer-Lean 2017 ‘Butchulla perspectives on dingo displacement and agency at K’gari-Fraser Island, Australia’ Geoforum 85, 197–205, doi: 10.1016/j.geoforum.2017.08.001
Despret, V 2016 [2012] What would animals say if we asked the right questions? B Buchanan (trans.) Ninneapolis and London: University of Minnesota Press.
Derrida, J 2009 The beast and the sovereign: volume 1 G Bennington (trans.) Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Dwyer, F 2015 Interview with author, Hervey Bay QLD, 27 November.
Donaldson, S and W Kymlicka 2016 ‘Between wildness and domestication: rethinking categories and boundaries in response to animal agency’ in B Bovenkerk and J Keulartz (eds) Animal ethics in the age of humans: blurring boundaries in human–animal relationships New York: Springer, 224-239.
Ecosure 2012 ‘Fraser Island Dingo Management Strategy Review’ report to Queensland Department of Environment and Heritage Protection, West Burleigh QLD.
Ecosure 2013 ‘Fraser Island Dingo Conservation and Risk Management Strategy’, Queensland Department of Environment and Heritage Protection, at https://www.ehp.qld.gov.au/wildlife/livingwith/dingoes/pdf/dingomanagement-strategy.pdf (accessed 6 April 2016).
Foucault, M 1995 Discipline and punish: the birth of the prison 2nd edn A Sheridan (trans.), New York: Vintage.
Hamilton, A 1972 ‘Aboriginal man’s best friend?’ Mankind 8 (4), 287–95.
Keane, J 2014 ‘Antarctica: notes on the fate of sovereignty’ The Conversation 24 June, at https://theconversation.com/antarctica-notes-on-the-fateof-sovereignty-28292 (accessed 12 March 2019).
Lennox, R 2013a ‘Head of a dog’ Southerly 73 (3), 212–26.
Lennox, R 2013b ‘What I’m reading’ Meanjin blog 2 December 2013, at https://meanjin.com.au/blog/what-im-reading-rowena-lennox/(accessed 12 March 2019)
Lennox, R 2014 ‘Apex predators’, Meanjin 73 (3): 6–9
Lennox, R 2016 ‘Coolooloi’ Authorised Theft: writing, scholarship, collaboration, refereed proceedings of the 21st conference of the Australasian Association of Writing Programs, Canberra, at http://www.aawp.org.au/wpcontent/uploads/2017/03/Lennox_AAWP_2016_Coolooloi.pdf. (accessed 12 March 2019)
Lennox, R 2017 ‘Killing Bold: managing the dingoes of Fraser Island’ Griffith Review 57, 255–70, at https://griffithreview.com/articles/killing-boldmanaging-the-dingoes-of-fraser-island/ (accessed 12 March 2019)
Lennox, R 2019a ‘Incessant: K’gari’s dingoes and Fraser Island contact history’ in Gillian Dooley and Danielle Clode (eds) The First Wave: exploring early coastal contact history in Australia Adelaide: Wakefield Press.
Lennox, R forthcoming Bold: ingenious dingoes of K’gari Sydney: Sydney University Press.
Lopez, B 2004 [1978] Of wolves and men New York: Scribner.
Macdonald, H 2014 H is for hawk London: Jonathan Cape.
Novak, D 2015 Interview with author, Eurong QLD, 26 November.
Parker, MA 2006, ‘Bringing the dingo home: discursive representations of the dingo by Aboriginal, colonial and contemporary Australians’ PhD thesis, School of English, Journalism and European Languages, University of Tasmania.
Parkhurst, J 2015 Interview with author, Rainbow Beach and K’gari QLD, 18–19 May.
Philip, J 2017 ‘Representing the dingo: an examination of dingo–human encounters in Australian cultural and environmental heritage’ PhD thesis, School of Ecosystem Management, Armidale: University of New England.
Probyn-Rapsey, F 2015 ‘Dingoes and dog-whistling: a cultural politics of race and species in Australia’ Animal Studies Journal 4 (2), 55–77, at http://ro.uow.edu.au/asj/vol4/iss2/4 (accessed 27 June 2018).
Rimmon-Kenan, S 1983 Narrative fiction: contemporary poetics London: Methuen
Rose, DB 2000 [1992] Dingo makes us human: life and land in Australian Aboriginal culture Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rose, DB 2011 Wild dog dreaming: love and extinction Charlottesville & London: University of Virginia Press.
Queensland government 2014 Department of Environment and Science, About Fraser Island dingoes, Dingo management on Fraser Island, Fraser Island Dingo Conservation and Risk Management Strategy, at https://parks.des.qld.gov.au/parks/fraser/dingo-management.html (accessed 5 March 2019)
Queensland government 2017–2018 Department of National Parks, Sport and Racing – disclosure log entries, Department of Environment and Science, at https://www.des.qld.gov.au/ourdepartment/rti/disclosure-log/npsr/ (accessed 19 November 2018)
QPWS (Queensland Parks and Wildlife Service) 2017 ‘The dingoes (wongari) of K’gari (Fraser Island): safety and information guide’ State of Queensland, Department of National Parks, Sport and Racing, at https://parks.des.qld.gov.au/parks/fraser/pdf/be-dingo-safe-flyer.pdf (accessed 17 December 2018)
Skelly, K 2015 Interview with author, Hervey Bay QLD, 25 November.
Wadiwel, D 2010 ‘A human right to stupidity: review of Jacques Derrida, The beast and the sovereign vol. 1’, Borderlands e-journal, 9 (3), at http://www.borderlands.net.au/vol9no3_2010/wadiwel_derrida.pdf (accessed 12 March 2019).
White, TH 1975 [1951] The goshawk Harmondsworth: Penguin.
